TO ORDER A WHOLE PIE:
For next day pick-up, place your order by 12 NOON*
For pickup at our 634 Dean Street PIE COUNTER call (347) 350 5110
For pickup at our 439 3rd Avenue PIE SHOP call (718) 499 2917
Salty Honey ®
Brown Butter Apple Streusel
Black Sesame Custard
Salted Caramel Apple
Chamomile Buttermilk Custard
Black Bottom Oat
Lavender Honey Custard
Bittersweet Chocolate Pecan
We sell WHOLE PIES & PIE BY THE SLICE IN OUR STORES.
The pie flavors listed on this menu are available for pre-order.
Please call us during business hours to place an order in advance.
We always have a selection of fresh whole pies in-store available for purchase first come, first served.
For pickup tomorrow of any of the pies listed on this menu, place your order before 12 NOON today*!
*Subject to availability
OUR MENU CHANGES
WITH THE SEASON
We source the best fruits locally when possible by the season, and also from the Western and Southern United States. Please see our ingredients page for more information about our products. Keep in touch, new flavors are always in the works.
WE SELL PIE BY THE SLICE
AND WHOLE PIES IN THE SHOP
A limited number of WHOLE PIES made with seasonal ingredients are available for purchase on a daily basis. We often have specialty pies available for purchase in the shop that are not listed on our pre-order menu above. You can always call the shop during business hours to find out what's in store!
CALL US TO ORDER YOUR FAVORITE WHOLE PIE
Orders are taken by phone during business hours on a first come, first served basis. To order a whole pie, PLEASE CALL THE SHOP (718) 499 2917. For next day pick-up, you must call the shop by 12 NOON. We are happy to answer your questions about pie flavors over the phone. We ship our pies through Goldbely! Please see our shipping page!
Our whole pies are $42. They are approximately 10 inches in size and serve 8–10 people.
All sales are final.