HOLIDAY PIES FAQ!


Should I refrigerate my pies? Yes. All pies should be refrigerated if not eaten within 24 hours of purchase. 

Our pies are freshly baked and contain no preservatives or artificial flavors! Wrap in plastic before refrigeration to maintain freshness and pie should last up to 5 days. Bring to room temperature before serving, or reheat as directed below. 

To warm pies: Bring oven to 250 ̊F and warm pie on a baking sheet for 15 minutes. Allow to sit for 10 minutes before slicing and serving. Salted Caramel Apple, Cranberry Apple Crumble and Cranberry Sage only. (Do not warm Egg ‘N’ Grogg.) 

I pre-ordered a pie, when can I pick up? BE SURE to pick up your pies on the day you booked! Pies can be picked up anytime during business hours on the day you booked. 

Bring your confirmation number with you. Our holiday hours are listed below.

I forgot to pre-order, can I still get a pie? We will have a selection of first come, first serve pies available for the holidays, on a limited basis during business hours. Come early to get yours! 


Can I change my order? All sales are final. Since your pie is hand made just for you, we cannot accommodate last minute switches or changes to pick up days or locations. 

Are you open on Christmas? We close at 12 noon on Christmas Eve and we will be closed Christmas day. 



holiday hours

634 Dean Street: PIE COUNTER

December 21: 8AM - 11PM

December 22: 9AM - 11PM

December 23: 9AM - 9PM

December 24: 8AM - 12 NOON

CLOSED CHRISTMAS DAY

NEW YEAR’S EVE: 8AM - 7PM

439 3rd Avenue: PIE SHOP

December 21: 8AM - 8PM

December 22: 9AM - 8PM

December 23: 10AM - 7PM

December 24: 8AM - 12 NOON

CLOSED CHRISTMAS DAY

NEW YEAR’S EVE: 8AM - 7PM

10 Grand Army Plaza:  BPL CAFE

December 21: 9am-6pm

December 22: 9am-6pm

December 23: 1pm-4pm

CLOSED December 24th

CLOSED CHRISTMAS DAY